The teacher understands the central concepts, tools of inquiry, and structure of the discipline(s) he or she teaches and can create learning experiences that make these aspects of subject matter meaningful for students.
It is not enough that a music teacher understands the principles and applications of his discipline; he must also be a skilled performer, an experienced musician, and a gifted artist.
"A violin master? He must be a violinist, a thinker, a poet, a human being, he must have known hope, love, passion and despair, he must have run the gamut of the emotions in order to express them all in his playing." -Eugene Ysaye
Reflection on the Learning Outcome
The second outcome of Case Western Reserve University's Proactive Scholar Practitioner Program is Subject Matter Knowledge. In order to fulfill this requirement, Case Western standards dictate that “the teacher understands the central concepts, tools of inquiry, and structure of the discipline(s) he or she teaches and can create learning experiences that make these aspects of subject matter meaningful for students.” In other words, teachers should be experienced in their field and know the ins and outs of the subject they teach. They should also understand how their discipline connects to other subjects, both academic and nonacademic. Furthermore, they should be familiar with ways of exploring their field and the resources and tools available for doing so. Finally and most importantly, they must be able to communicate their knowledge and love of the subject to their students by using the experience they have gained and their creative mindset.
This standard mandates that music teachers be skilled performers, knowledgeable in musical fields and resources, and be able to pass on that knowledge and love of music to their pupils. Music educators should be talented soloists as well as chamber music and orchestral performers. Their performance knowledge should also encompass a broad variety of musical genres, not limited to the classical style. They should be well educated in all aspects of music as a whole, including music history and music theory, but they should also have a well-rounded comprehension of the other liberal arts as well and how music fits into the other aspects of academia. Music teachers should have a knowledge of common educational materials, methods, and philosophies and the resources that are available to them to help their pupils succeed. They should also understand the technical and musical progression that a student makes, and know which materials to use at which stage of the student's musical growth. Finally, they must love music and have both the fervent desire and ability to pass that love on to their pupils.
Opportunities to develop these skills abound both inside and outside the classroom. At Case Western, the arts and sciences program and required music education core provide an abundance of formal instruction, from instrumental methods classes to physics lectures. Case's music program within the context of a fine liberal arts education ensures that future music teachers will be provided with the tools to become a true musical scholar. Performances in recital class as a soloist and in concerts as part of an ensemble both develop future teachers' performance skills as do private lessons. Outside of formal academia, attending summer camps, participating in research, giving recitals, and listening to lectures and master classes are all excellent ways of improving in subject matter knowledge.
Possibilities for artifacts are as numerous as the opportunities for subject matter knowledge growth. Some ideas for demonstrating mastery of musical fields are essays or projects from music history or theory and formal transcripts displaying courses taken. For performance knowledge, recordings or video of one's concerts are excellent artifacts as are music related awards and competition ratings and lists of repertoire performed. Other ideas for subject matter knowledge artifacts are videos of teaching episodes, essays or reviews of music materials and methods, evidence of attending festivals or lectures, and a biography listing previous playing and teaching experience.