<p align=center><font size=5>Maria Cisneros<br>Teacher Education Portfolio</font></

  1. Introduction to Education
    1. Philosophy
    2. Research
      1. PowerPoint
      2. References
    3. Critical Analysis
    4. Pro/Con Issue
    5. Final Reflection
  2. Cultural Diversity in Education
    1. Philosophy
    2. Research
      1. Research Paper
      2. References
      3. Handout
      4. "Model Minority" PowerPoint
    3. Critical Analysis
    4. Teaching Strategy
    5. Calendar
    6. Final Reflection
  3. Technology
    1. Philosophy of Technology
    2. PowerPoint
    3. Computer Science
    4. Internet Web
    5. Windows XP
      1. Resource Manual
    6. Great Education Links
    7. WebQuests
      1. Shark WebQuest
    8. Publisher
      1. Class Calendar
      2. Special Interest Group Flyer
      3. Classroom Newsletter
      4. Class Website
      5. Read-Aloud Brochure
      6. Publisher E-mail
  4. History
    1. Educational Plan
    2. Ranching Frontier PowerPoint
    3. Worksheets and Activities
    4. Materials Used
    5. Curriculum
  5. Theory of Elementary Math I & II
    1. Philosophy of Elementary Mathematics
    2. Service Learning Reflection (St. Anne Little Flower)
    3. Math Literature Lesson - Fractions
    4. Math Literature Lesson - How Much is a Million
    5. Temperature Conversion Team Lesson
    6. Placing the Value on Digits: An Internet Lesson
    7. Great Math Links
    8. Calculators
  6. Relationships in a Classroom Setting
    1. Philosophy
    2. Research
    3. Classroom Rules
    4. Within a Mile of Home: A Final Reflection
    5. Classroom Layout
    6. Classroom Newsletter and Chill Out Form
  7. Child Development
    1. Philosophy of Child Development
    2. History of Child Development
    3. Evaluation of a Toy
    4. Effects of Premature Birth
    5. Focusing on Cognitive Development
    6. Special Interest Group Proposal
    7. Concept of Whole Child
    8. Final Reflection
  8. Children's Literature
    1. Sparking a Love for Literature: A Children's Literature Philosophy
    2. Dear Meatball: A Service Learning Tale
    3. Literature Rich Classroom Layout
    4. Reading Aloud to Children
    5. Motivating Teachers to Motivate Students
    6. Literature Lessons
      1. From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler
      2. Yakov and the Seven Thieves
    7. Letter to Parents
  9. Introduction to Exceptional Learner
    1. Philosophy of Exceptional Learner
    2. Service Learning Reflection
    3. Computer Resource Manual
Home > Course Work > Cultural Diversity in Education > Critical Analysis

Critical Analysis

Differences are Priceless
white teacher.jpg

For a teacher, a top priority is to promote and celebrate diversity in the classroom. For some teachers, that may not be such a difficult concept. Being Mexican-American has given me the opportunity to interact with different cultures, and I strongly believe that it will be easier for me to accept and understand other cultures in my classroom one day. Others, in contrast, have not had the opportunity to experience cultures outside their own. One such person is Vivian Gussin Paley (1979) in her book White Teacher. In this novel, Paley presents a very honest account of her experience as a teacher in an integrated classroom. It is a very powerful novel that tells of her progress in discovering how to deal with both her students’ and her own awareness of racial diversity. Throughout most of the book, Paley believes that the best way to deal with the differences in her class is by ignoring them. By the end, however, Paley realizes just how critical it is for teachers to recognize the differences amongst the children in their classrooms. By recognizing these differences instead of ignoring them, teachers, like Paley, can establish a very positive classroom environment in which children will readily learn and thrive.

*Graphic found at www.overstock.com

Positive Differences

positive.jpg One of the most important reasons why teachers should celebrate racial differences rather than ignore them, is because it allows children of different races to feel proud and confident about their differences. At the beginning of the book, Paley tells of a comrade whose philosophy is that color doesn’t matter, all her children are the same (12). Paley then tells of a parent’s reaction to this: “My children are black. They don’t look like your children. They know they’re black, and we want it recognized. It’s a positive difference, an interesting difference, and a comfortable natural difference. At least it could be so, if you teachers learned to value differences more. What you value, you talk about” (12). If every teacher treated all “different” children like they were “White”, these children could grow up thinking that there is something terribly wrong with being Asian, for example, and they would be ashamed of their heritage and culture. Diversity in the classroom is a beautiful thing. If it is celebrated, children grow up knowing their culture and having a positive sense of self.

Experiencing Other Cultures

globe.jpg Another reason teachers should acknowledge diversity is because it gives students from the predominant culture the opportunity to experience cultures outside their own. Through diversity in the classroom, they develop a sense of what awaits them when they step into the real world. If White children are exposed only to a white environment, they could feel awkward and perhaps a little prejudiced around minorities after they stepped out of the classroom. By bringing children of different backgrounds together, they will learn to value their differences, and will learn to feel completely at ease in situations where they are surrounded by cultures unlike their own.

Promoting Equality

stereotype.jpg

Differences should also be recognized instead of ignored in the classroom because it promotes equality and furthermore, exposing children to other cultures helps break stereotypes that they might have been exposed to. Paley sees this in her classroom one day. “White people tell lies,” (104) says a little girl in her class one day. “That’s right, they do tell lies,” answers the little girl’s friend. Paley overhears this conversation, and realizes that the black children in her class often point out negative things when they speak of the White children, or all White people in general. For this very reason, children should learn about the different cultures that surround them.

*Personal clipart

A Positive Adulthood

cooperation.jpg

A peaceful and accepting world begins in the classroom. Exposing children to the differences that surround them, instead of hiding them helps to promote diversity and acceptance. By setting this positive accepting classroom climate, teachers give their students the opportunity to experience cultures outside their own, which opens the door to a very positive and accepting adulthood.

Author: Maria Cisneros
Last modified: 9/13/2005 1:35 PM (EST)